📰 What Happened

TVB’s Scoop recently received a plea for help from a 23-year-old female student, Ms. Tsui, who came forward about an “online dating” scam. Struggling with depression, Ms. Tsui admitted she didn’t have many friends her own age. Craving social connection, she searched “Hong Kong dating” on a social platform in mid-July to meet people.

Along the way she met a “Ms. Chan,” who claimed to be a part-time compensated dating girl and quickly sent over revealing photos and a price list. Ms. Tsui had no intention of paying for sex, but she felt a pull to “find innocence in the mud” — she wanted to become this person’s confidante, to comfort and “save” her as someone who’d been there herself.

That “kind” impulse turned out to be exactly the opening the scammer needed. The two agreed to meet at a convenience store, but Ms. Chan stood her up and passed Ms. Tsui’s phone number to a man claiming to be “the triad member who drove her there.” Using the excuse of “making sure the girl is safe and verifying you’re not a cop,” he tricked Ms. Tsui into handing over a photo of her HKID and her employment details.

Then the mask came off: the man demanded up to HK$1 million as a “meeting deposit.” After Ms. Tsui said she was just an unemployed student, the amount kept “slashing” — from 1 million down to 500,000, then 20,000, and finally, “the triad boss is willing to front 15,000, so you only need to pay 5,000.”

Ms. Tsui, who couldn’t even come up with 5,000, soon received several profanity-laced “triad threat videos” claiming they already had her HKID details and would send a thug to check on her family. (The program later pointed out these videos were actually recycled stock clips the scammers reused.) In the end, terrified her family would be harassed, Ms. Tsui rushed straight into the Mong Kok police station to file a report — and only then did the scammers hang up and delete their accounts.

👩‍💼 The Advisor’s Take

On the surface, this looks like a straightforward “dating scam.” But if you treat it as an ordinary scam, you’ll miss the most important layer — why did a kind-hearted girl who was studying, and even hoping to “help someone,” slide into it step by step? There are actually several psychological mechanisms at play, and every Hongkonger should be on guard.

① The Savior Complex: People Who Want to Save Others Are the Easiest to Exploit

The whole thing started with a very particular idea: Ms. Tsui wasn’t looking to take advantage of anyone. She wanted to “find innocence in the mud” and “save” the other person.

In psychology, this mindset is called the Savior Complex (or White Knight Syndrome) — a person who gains self-worth and a sense of purpose through “rescuing others.” Often, the root of this complex is an emptiness within: you yourself long to be accepted and needed, so you project that longing onto “saving” someone else.

The problem is, a person who genuinely needs saving won’t show up on a social platform with “revealing photos + a price list.” The moment you decide you “want to save someone,” you’ve already lowered your defenses and even started rationalizing the scammer’s behavior for them — “she just went astray, I can help her.” Scammers love this kind of “self-persuading” person, because they don’t even have to deceive you — you’re already deceiving yourself.

② Loneliness and Depression: An Emotional Gap Is a Scammer’s “Front-Door Key”

Two keywords stand out in Ms. Tsui’s background: depression and a lack of friends.

Put those two together and you get exactly the “emotional gap” scammers crave most. Psychological research shows that loneliness makes our brains especially sensitive to signals of “being accepted,” while at the same time sharply lowering our alertness to “danger.” The lonelier you are, the easier it is to misread “someone reached out to chat” as “someone genuinely wants to know me.”

So understand this: the first step in these scams is never about taking your money — it’s about “filling your loneliness.” The scammer pretends to care, to understand, to be going through the same pain as you, making you feel like you’re finally “being seen.” Once that feeling of “being needed” is established, you’ll willingly walk toward them — and only then does the “money grab” begin.

③ Four-Step Manipulation: From a “Small Ask” to “Fear That Locks You In”

Looking back at the whole process, it’s a very standard psychological manipulation flow that can be broken down into four steps:

Step 1: “Build trust” — they play the victim, feign sincerity, and get you to lower your guard.
Step 2: “The foot-in-the-door technique” (psychologists call it Foot-in-the-door — first getting a foot inside) — they won’t ask you for 1 million right away. Instead, they first ask you to “send your HKID to verify your identity.” This request sounds “reasonable,” even like it’s “for your own protection,” so you naturally comply. Once you’ve made that first small concession, the demands keep growing, because your subconscious wants to “stay consistent.”
Step 3: “Exploit sunk cost” — once you’ve handed over your HKID, it’s very hard to walk away. You’re afraid “everything I’ve already given will be wasted,” afraid “they’re holding something of mine.” That “I’ve come this far, might as well see it through” mindset is exactly what the manipulator wants.
Step 4: “Fear that locks you in” — they use triad videos to create fear, so you won’t dare report it or tell anyone. Fear is the final lock: they want you to feel that “speaking up will cause trouble,” so you’ll quietly comply and stay silent.

The detail most worth noting is the “slashing from 1 million down to 5,000.” Many people assume the scammer was “going soft” or “didn’t really care” — but it’s actually a very clever manipulation trick: when an astronomical figure suddenly becomes “just 5,000,” you think, “it’s so cheap, might as well just pay and be done with it.” But the truth is, they never cared about that 5,000 — what they wanted was the act of you “submitting.” The moment you cave, you’ve proven the manipulation works, and more demands will only follow.

💡 What You Can Learn

So how can ordinary people protect themselves? Here are three principles that hold true in any situation.

First, recognize the red flags. Being asked for your HKID, bank details, or a deposit before ever meeting is always a red flag — no exceptions. A real friend will never ask you for money, your HKID, or a guarantee deposit. And there are two hidden red flags to watch: when the conversation quickly turns to “sex” or “money,” and when someone “stands you up” and a “second person” (a triad member, a manager, a guarantor) immediately pops up to talk to you — these are all part of the playbook.

Second, any relationship takes time. Wanting to make friends when you’re lonely is a perfectly normal need, but remember this: real relationships are built over time. Nobody “just happens” to need you to prove something or hand something over right away. If someone is in a rush for you to “prove your sincerity,” that in itself is a warning sign.

Third, when something feels off, stop. Ms. Tsui did one thing right in the end — she rushed into a police station and filed a report, which is what forced the scammers to back off. If you find yourself in a similar situation, don’t worry about feeling awkward or being laughed at. Stop responding immediately, talk to someone you trust, and report it to the police right away if needed. You’re not stupid — you were just lonely, and someone exploited your kindness. It’s not your fault, but you do need to know how to protect yourself.

At the end of the day, wanting to help others and wanting to be loved aren’t wrong. But before you open the door to your heart, remember to leave a gate for yourself. If you’re going through loneliness, or you suspect you’re being manipulated, talk to a love advisor at LoveWise — we’re always here to talk…💕

🔥 戀愛熱話

女生揀另一半其實更睇樣？研究揭「口嫌體正直」真相｜愛情顧問解說

「AI 伴侶」殺到香港：人會唔會愛上機械人？｜愛情顧問解說

「女人 GPA 高都無用」中大教授「釣金龜」論引爆爭議｜愛情顧問解說

「女人 GPA 高都無用」中大教授「釣金龜」論引爆爭議｜愛情顧問解說

識男友先睇八字、擇偶要研究骨相？香港人點解越嚟越信玄學揀對象｜愛情顧問解說

政府氹你生仔加碼派錢，香港人點解仲係唔肯生？｜愛情顧問解說

想用愛感化「援交妹」反墮騙局：善良同孤獨，點解會成為騙徒嘅目標？｜愛情顧問解說

香港人點解「唔敢結婚生仔」？拆解遲婚、樓價同生育嘅連鎖困局｜愛情顧問解說

拍拖越來越貴：4 成港人因錢分手，情侶談錢點樣先唔傷感情？｜愛情顧問解說

香港結婚登記兩年連跌：近半係再婚，真正「首次結婚」其實更少｜愛情顧問解說

陳妍希離婚後不再信天長地久：想生二胎「沒機會了」｜愛情顧問解說

香港人口調查：123萬適婚男女未婚，本地「剩男」多「剩女」3萬——「女多男少」點解反而男仔更難搵對象？｜愛情顧問解說

Edan 霸氣認追林明禎：公開認愛係勇氣定壓力？姊弟戀點先走得穩？｜愛情顧問解說

交友 App 集體倦怠：滑極都係嗰班人，新一代點解重返現實識人？｜愛情顧問解說

不婚不生浪潮升溫：全球最低生育率背後，單身係自由定係遺憾？｜愛情顧問解說

前TVB主播容家耀、林可瑩公開戀情：由「探古尋源」拍檔變戀人，「最佳旅伴」點解咁浪漫？｜愛情顧問解說

馬景濤 64 歲娶細 26 年女友｜愛情顧問拆解「忘年戀」三大現實考量

楊玉梅縮沙入豪門：「一夫多妻、生仔機器」——嫁入豪門真係愛情童話？｜愛情顧問解說

Angelababy 離婚 4 年傳譜姊弟戀：女大男小差 17 年，年齡差距真係問題嗎？｜愛情顧問解說

黃子華×劉嘉玲《香港式離婚》88萬人搶飛：點解香港人咁鍾意睇離婚？｜愛情顧問解說

韓劇《好吧離婚吧》熱播：點解「7 年之癢」唔係都市傳說？婚姻嘅七年關口｜愛情顧問解說